20% Off Memorial Day Sale - Code: REMEMBER (exclusions)

Translation missing: en.general.currency.dropdown_label

Promotional Banner
natural mascara

Mascara

Discover the unique experience of wearing natural mascara. These natural mascaras volumize and lengthen  eyelashes with nourishing formulas.  Natural mascaras are safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.  Achieve beautiful natural looking lashes that last all day.
Agent Nateur holi (lash) growth mascara
$43.00
Unit price
per 
TOK Beauty Eyes That TOK Mascara
$28.00
Unit price
per 
Lily Lolo Mascara
$20.00
Unit price
per 
Fitglow Beauty Good Lash+ Mascara
$38.00
Unit price
per 
Lily Lolo Big Lash Mascara
$22.00
Unit price
per 
Inika Organic Long Lash Mascara
$35.00
Unit price
per 
Ere Perez Avocado Mascara - black
$29.00
Unit price
per 
Plume Science Nourish & Amplify Mascara
$24.00 - $36.00
Unit price
per 
100 Pure Fruit Pigmented Ultra Lengthening Mascara
$30.00
Unit price
per 
Fitglow Plum Lash Primer
$28.00
Unit price
per 
Inika Organic Purity Lash Mascara Black
$36.00
Unit price
per 
Kosas The Big Clean Mascara MINI
$13.00
Unit price
per 
Plume Science Curl & Lift Lash Curler
$21.00
Unit price
per 
HAN Skincare Cosmetics Mascara
$20.00
Unit price
per 
RMS Beauty Clean & Bright Kit On Sale
$89.00 $48.00
Unit price
per 
withSimplicity Botanical Mascara
$20.00
Unit price
per 
Hynt Beauty Flyrt Mascara
$29.00
Unit price
per 
Ere Perez Natural Almond Mascara
$29.00
Unit price
per 
RÓEN Beauty Cake Mascara
$28.00
Unit price
per 
100% Pure Maracuja Mascara Black
$28.00
Unit price
per 
Antonym Cosmetics mascara
$26.00
Unit price
per 
Ere Perez Spectacular Eyelash Curler
$21.00
Unit price
per 
Zuzu Luxe Mascara
$19.35
Unit price
per 
Gabriel Cosmetics Mascara
$17.60
Unit price
per 
agent nateur lash growth duo
$161.00
Unit price
per 
Zao Organic Makeup Aloe Vera Mascara  Black
$32.00
Unit price
per 
Inika Organic Bold Lash Mascara Black
$36.00
Unit price
per 
Inika Organic Curvy Lash Mascara Black
$35.00
Unit price
per 
Alima Pure Mascara Black
$30.00
Unit price
per 

Best Natural Mascara Products

Nourish & Amplify Mascara

Renee - "Good natural look. This is a very Natural Mascara look. You will not get bold thick lashes from the mascara, so keep in mind if that is what you are looking for, this won't be the right mascara for you. But I like a more natural look and love the fact of growing my lashes as well :)"
 
Jessica - "Very Impressed. The first time I put it on I was extremely impressed with how good this Natural Mascara is."
 
Lisa - "Better than expected. I have to say I’m very skeptical any time I try something new but Plume didn’t disappoint with this natural mascara. It is really quite wonderful."

Good Lash + Mascara

Morgan - "Great clean Natural Mascara! I bought this after seeing Tati rave about it in one of her videos. Once again, she was right! This mascara makes my lashes voluminous and they hold a curl! The only thing is at the very top of my lashes they can stick together. But nothing that a lash comb can’t fix! So happy to find a clean, good-for-you Natural Mascara!"
 
Ellen - "Good Lash Mascara. Love this Natural Mascara, No clumping or flaking, just nice full pretty lashes. Would highly rec and buy again:)"
 
Yvette - "Great Natural Mascara! Very voluminous lashes with no smudges. I sometimes come home and take a nap working early hours and wake up with no smudges!! Love Fitglow products!"

Fullest Volumizing Mascara

Paula - "Great Mascara. I am very pleased with this Natural Mascara. It goes on easily, does not clump, and does not rub off (unless you really are rubbing at your eyes). It also washes off easily. All day staying power and gives a fuller lash than others I have tried. Would definitely recommend it."
 
Gianna - "I'm in love with this Natural Mascara! The formula is rich without clumping and the brush is exactly as it should be! It gave my lashes amazing volume."
 
Gloria - "I love this Natural Mascara! I love that it’s natural. I wish the brush had a separator on one side, but it’s still great. But my favorite part is it comes off easily at night."

Long Lash Mascara

Natasha - "One of the best! I love this Natural Mascara and I have tried my fair share. Length and volume for sure! And doesn’t run under my eyes as others do."
 
Brittany - "Best mascara. This is my favorite Natural Mascara. It doesn’t clump or flake. It really darkens and lengthens my lashes. It doesn’t smudge. Your lashes look so good using this!"
 
Sam - "Love it! I'm honestly super picky about mascaras and have found it difficult to find a Natural Mascara that I like as much as non-natural ones. This one works great!!! No clumping or flaking, and my lashes even look better without mascara since using this one! "

Eyes That TOK Mascara

Marty - "I really like this Natural Mascara. Its staying power is great. Looks very natural and not clumpy. I would like a different brush so I use one I have. I would buy it again."
 
Lorna - "LOVE THIS NATURAL MASCARA. This is the best mascara I have ever used. No clumping, flaking, or under-eye smearing. It is water resistant which is less drying/damaging for my senior lashes. For years I used waterproof mascara until I discovered this one on Instagram. This Natural Mascara is Canadian and offers clean and safe beauty products. ❤️ "
 
Margaret- "THE BEST NATURAL MASCARA! I have used many types of mascara, from very expensive to very cheap. By far, this is the best product that I’ve used in a long time. My lashes have never looked so long and it is very easy to remove. I highly recommend this product."

Avocado Mascara

Amy - "Fabulous For A Green Beauty Natural Mascara. The most difficult product to find in Green Beauty is hands down good mascara! For one thing, I tend to have oily eyelids even with primer and I need a dryer product to work with or it turns into a mess by smudging & clumping. I have naturally long eyelashes they just need a bit of beefing up & I want it in one pass. This is it!"
 
Karay - "A must-have Natural Mascara! Absolutely love! My curl holds when I put it on and this layers nicely. Will be repurchasing!"
 
Danielle - "The only mascara I wear, This is the only clean Natural Mascara I’ve found that keeps my curl intact. Every other brand has water in the first few ingredients and what does water do to curls Yup, pulls them right out(learned this years ago from Wayne Goss). This doesn’t run or flake off and I feel like it’s pretty buildable. A definite favorite of mine."

Luxe Mascara

Emily - "Good stuff. I got the clear Natural Mascara to try on my lashes, and I think it looks great! It's very subtle but adds definition. I do wish it had a lasting shine. I haven't used a mascara since the first time I tried one and it irritated my eyes horribly, which this one does not do. It also works very well on brows."
 
Sheryl - "Fast shipping. Good service. I really like this Natural Mascara product. It works for me really well. Some products cause a rash on the eyelid, but this does not cause irritation."
 
Emily C. - " Must Have! This is my go-to all-time favorite clean Natural Mascara! I have tried so many in the past and this one lasts all day and has a great brush for application that really extends my lashes and makes them look full. Best of all, I find that it stays put unlike other clean mascaras, I don't have to worry about having mascara under my eyes mid-day!"

Fruit Pigmented Ultra Lengthening Mascara

Quinn - "Natural Mascara. I loveee the ingredients in this and the chocolatey smell! I can tell this is an all-natural product and I don't have to worry about what I am putting on my eyelashes. Definitely a 10/10 for me. Lasts long, gives volume, and is overall perfect! I have the dark chocolate one!"
 
Alanah - "Top Natural Mascara On the Market. If you are new to clean beauty, this product is a must! It is one of the best clean beauty mascaras and the price is comparable to any high-end brand you could find at Sephora. They smell divine and they really help nourish your eyelashes."
 
Jessica - "Excellent, clean Natural Mascara, Cleanest mascara out there! This is a great formula that gives nice definition and color to lashes, although it’s not super duper lengthening; part of this, I think, is due to the brush shape. Sometimes, I swap out other mascara brushes and use them with this product. No flaking!"