20% Off Earth Day Sale - Code: EARTH (exclusions)

Translation missing: en.general.currency.dropdown_label

Promotional Banner
natural eyeliners

Eyeliners

A Natural Eyeliner adds definition and structure to your eyes. They offer the perfect way to enhance your eyes and create a dramatic subtle or smoky look. If you prefer a classic pencil formula or a modern liquid version, natural eyeliner products give you the freedom to create the look you want.
Inika Organic Liquid Eyeliner Black
$32.00
Unit price
per 
Ere Perez Jojoba Eye Pencil
$24.00
Unit price
per 
Antonym Cosmetics Eye Pencil Black Noir
$21.00
Unit price
per 
Zuzu Liquid Eyeliner
$17.15
Unit price
per 
100 Pure Creamy Long Last Eyeliner
$27.00
Unit price
per 
Sigma WICKED LIQUID PEN EYELINER
$20.00
Unit price
per 
RMS Beauty Straight Line Kohl Eye Pencil
$23.00
Unit price
per 
Inika Organic Eye Pencil
$23.00
Unit price
per 
Gabriel Cosmetics Classic Eye Liner
$13.20
Unit price
per 
Lily Lolo Eye Pencil
$16.00
Unit price
per 
Zao Organic Makeup Eyeliner
$27.00
Unit price
per 
Alima Pure Natural Definition Eye Pencil
$26.00
Unit price
per 
Lily Lolo Eye Liner - Smudge Brush
$11.00
Unit price
per 
RÓEN Beauty Sharpener
$2.00
Unit price
per 
Fitglow Beauty Vegan Eyeliner Pencil
$24.00
Unit price
per 
Antonym Cosmetics Eyebrow Pencil Medium brown
$25.00
Unit price
per 
100 Pure Liquid Eye Liner Sold Out
$30.00
Unit price
per 

Best Natural Eyeliner Products

Clean Line Gel Liner

Elena - "Great Natural Eyeliner. Really enjoy using this gel eyeliner. I did find it does smudge slightly by the end of day, but definitely will purchase again."
 
Makay - "Perfect. This Natural Eyeliner is perfect, and is easy to build for a solid, crisp look. It has fantastic staying power, and it is now going to be the only eyeliner that I will continue to repurchase, as I don't need to search anymore."
 
Abby - "Great! This is a fantastic Natural Eyeliner! I love the liquid liner too, but this I use for a more natural look. Also, love Ilia's mascara!"

Jojoba Eye Pencil

Marie - "Love this eye pencil. Have purchased several before ordering from safe and chic Will come back for more I am sure. This natural eyeliner product is gentle, soft, not toxic on my eyes."
 
Jillian - "Lovely Natural Eyeliner. I have the colors Bronze & Agate. They are my go-to eyeliners. They are gentle on the eyes & such beautiful colors!"
 
Margot - "Natural Eyeliner Pencil - stone color. Found this in NYC when I ran out of eye pencil and wondered how I would find it again and sure enough googled it and purchased it from Safe & Chic-I love it-so natural looking!!"

Liquid Eyeliner

Amy - "I've been wearing this organic Liquid Eyeliner in the shade of "Brown" for approximately a year with excellent results. Since I don't wear much in the way of cosmetics on a constant basis I usually wear it on the top eyelid either as a nude look or over a touch of eye-shadow & am always in a rush! Given all of that I'm still very pleased with the results which never smudge, stay in place all day until sometimes late evening & never disappoint. The product comes with a wonderful liner which does a fabulous job of gliding on the eyelid either very slim or just as thick and perfect as demanded."
 
Sophia- "Stays on well. I like to have both this liquid Natural Eyeliner, and their eye pencil on hand, as the pencil is easier to work with, but the liquid liner stays better :)"
 
Christina- "Love this Natural Eyeliner. The smooth formula glides on thin with a lot of pigment so I don't have to build it up like a lot of others which are light until you build 2-3 layers on."

Classic Eye Liner

Marty - " I like this Natural Eyeliner. I got the pine color it’s pretty. I also used it as an eyeshadow. It went on smoothly and lasted. I have not used it on the water line yet to see if it has staying power there. I will purchase this brand again."
 
CotyLynn - "Perfect for sensitive eyes. Great Natural Eyeliner. Super silky. It also pairs very nicely with eye shadow because the eyeliner is silky and the eye shadow clings to it, preventing smudging. Also, my eyes are so sensitive to cheaper products but this one can stay on all day long with no complaints!"
 
Patricia - "Best Natural Eyeliner ever. What a great find. The application is easy and it stays on! This liner is now essential. Get it!"

Clean Line Liquid Liner - Midnight Express

Christina - "This Natural Eyeliner is perfect for sensitive eyes. Love it.. great applicator and staying power without any eye irritation."
 
Casey - "Best Clean Liquid Natural Eyeliner Out There. This is truly the best clean liquid eyeliner I have ever had. Actually best clean natural eyeliner period. I was using Alcones liquid liner before this and could never find one superior to it until now. I only wear this on my top lid, but that said, I have really oily lids and this has never run despite that! I never have raccoon eyes by the end of the day, and it last all day and night and sometimes the next day too lol. I have black and it is actually black. So, yes, buy it!"
 
Amy - "Fantastic Liquid Eyeliner. This is the best clean liquid Natural Eyeliner I've found. A thin line is easy, it doesn't flake, and stays on all day."

Creamy Long Lasting Eyeliner

Robin - "Excellent Natural Eyeliner product, Finally an eyeliner pencil that glides on smoothly. Looks fantastic and is gentle on my eyes. Some liners make my eyes water but not this one. So pleased with my purchase!"
 
Alanah - "Best Natural Eyeliner pencil. I loveeee this eye pencil in Dark Cacao! It does not easily transfer and is almost more matte than other clean beauty eye pencils I have tried. It does take some work but with some heat, it can be really creamy. I prefer more matte so this is great! Really easily blendable."
 
Jessica "Awesome, clean Natural Eyeliner. This is a great—and the cleanest out there—eyeliner. It has a nice creamy formula that is comfortable to put on and lasts all day. I notice that it does tend to smudge a bit in the outer corners of my eyes if I don’t set it with the bamboo translucent powder right away. If you do that, though, no smudging!"

Nourish & Line Liquid Eyeliner

L.P. - "I've been using this Natural Eyeliner for a few weeks and I really love it. It is long-wearing and doesn’t smudge throughout the day. I also like how it removes easily with makeup remover and doesn’t stain my skin. I highly recommend this product." 👍
 
B.S. - "Huge fan of this Natural Eyeliner! I love how easy it is to use, how great the applicator is, and the fact that the lash serum properties are in this too! Love it - definitely my favorite liquid liner!"
 
E.T. "Absolutely ADORE this Natural Eyeliner. I’ve been toxin free going on 7 years and I have not used such a wonderful eyeliner as this one! Does not smudge, dried quickly, easy to apply. Above and beyond would recommend 10/10."

The Black Orb Enigmatic Kohl Eyeliner

Rachel - "I love this Black Orb Natural Eyeliner in Black, also now available in Iron too! It’s so different. It’s such a lovely representation of the color. It really makes my hazel eyes pop. As a wearer of glasses that can make my eyes look smaller, I love something simple that can make them stand out more. Iron does that."
 
Sarah - "A unique color for an eyeliner, flattering, and easy to work with. I use this Natural Eyeliner in Abyss fairly regularly, and I find that the formula is fairly consistent—that is, the top layer is a bit dry, but once you are through that, it is easy to create clean lines. It’s also fairly easy to avoid over-applying, which can cause transfer if you have hooded lids like me."
 
Amendoa - "Exquisite Natural Eyeliner. The texture of this liner is smooth and applies well with an angled brush. The color and the color payoff are incredible. This color is unexpected and I love it. It’s not easy finding reds for eyes and this one doesn’t disappoint. The only thing that would make it better is waterproof or more water resistant as my eyes tend to water."